Skip to main content

Trail running shoe comparison tool: 21 head-to-heads (2026)

The most complete trail shoe comparison tool: 21 duels between the most searched models, with brand-stated specs, a hexagon showing where each one wins, and a cross-check with our races to see which suits your terrain and distance.

Updated September 2026

Our best trail running shoes, by what you need

Don’t want to compare? Start here: one model per need, chosen only from verified brand specs.

Compare up to 5 at once

Type a model, pick it from the list and see them all in columns. The best in each row is highlighted in green.

    Trail shoe comparisons by type of duel

    Grouped by what you are deciding: ultra, technical terrain, zero drop or the everyday classics.

    Hexagon: lightness, cushioning, grip, stability, technical terrain and ultra

    Grip and technical terrain shoes

    Deep lugs for mud, rock and technical descents.

    Every trail running shoe at a glance

    Brand-stated specs for the 24 models we compare. Swipe to see all columns.

    Trail shoe comparison table: weight, drop, cushioning and lugs
    ModelWeightDropHeelLugsBest forBuy
    Altra Lone Peak 9295 g0 mm25 mm3.8 mmMixed trailCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Altra Olympus 6357 g0 mm35 mm3.5 mmUltra, Smooth trail, Mixed trailCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Altra Superior 7264 g0 mm21 mm3.5 mmSmooth trail, Mixed trailCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Altra Timp 5269 g0 mm29 mm3 mmSmooth trail, Mixed trailCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Asics Gel-Trabuco 14 GTX281 g8 mm36 mm3.7 mmUltra, Mixed trail, Smooth trailCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Asics Trabuco Max 5302 g5 mm38.5 mm3.5 mmUltra, Smooth trail, Mixed trailCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Brooks Caldera 8309 g6 mm36.7 mm3.6 mmUltra, Smooth trail, Mixed trailCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Brooks Cascadia 18314 g8 mm33 mm4 mmMixed trailCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Brooks Cascadia Elite278 g6 mm40 mm3.5 mmUltra, Smooth trail, Mixed trailCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Hoka Challenger 8275 g8 mm42 mm3.7 mmUltra, Smooth trail, Mixed trailCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Hoka Mafate 5332 g8 mm45 mm4.4 mmUltra, Mixed trail, Technical terrainCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Hoka Speedgoat 7275 g4 mm37 mm4.5 mmUltra, Mixed trail, Technical terrainCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Hoka Tecton X3292 g5 mm40 mm4 mmUltra, Mixed trail, Technical terrainCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Hoka Zinal 2211 g5 mm30 mm5 mmMixed trail, Technical terrainCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Merrell Agility Peak 5300 g6 mm39 mm4.5 mmUltra, Mixed trailCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Merrell Agility Peak 6278 g6 mm32 mm5 mmMixed trail, Technical terrain, MudCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    New Balance Fresh Foam X Hierro v9297 g4 mm33 mm3.3 mmMixed trailCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    NNormal Kjerag200 g6 mm23.5 mm3 mmTechnical terrainCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Salomon Genesis 2283 g8 mm33.5 mm4 mmMixed trail, Technical terrainCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Salomon Speedcross 6298 g10 mm32 mm5.8 mmMudCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Salomon Speedcross 6 GTX328 g10 mm32 mm5 mmMudCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Salomon XA Pro 3D Gore-Tex360 g11 mm28.7 mm3.5 mmMixed trail, Technical terrainCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Saucony Peregrine 16271 g4 mm32 mm3.5 mmMixed trail, Technical terrainCheck price(opens in a new tab)
    Saucony Xodus Ultra 4312 g6 mm37.6 mm3.5 mmUltra, Mixed trailCheck price(opens in a new tab)

    Trail running shoe FAQ

    What is the drop of a trail running shoe?

    Drop is the height difference between heel and forefoot, in millimetres. A low drop (0–4 mm) encourages a more natural, forefoot-oriented stride; a high one (8–10 mm) relieves calves and Achilles. If you change drop, do it gradually. See the Lone Peak 9 vs Olympus 6 duel as a zero-drop example.

    What is stack height and how much do I need?

    Stack is the total height of foam between your foot and the ground. More stack means more cushioning and comfort over long distances, but less ground feel and sometimes less stability. Ultras usually call for more stack; technical short mountain runs for less.

    What are lugs and what depth is best?

    Lugs are the raised patterns on the outsole. With 3–4 mm you get good grip on dirt and dry rock; with 5–6 mm or more, in mud and soft ground. Very deep lugs grip more but feel odd on tarmac and hard trail. Check the lug row in the comparison.

    What is a wide toe box and when does it help?

    A wide toe box gives toes room to splay when pushing off and keeps them from squeezing on long descents. It helps if you get blisters or your feet swell on ultras. A narrow fit gives more precision and hold on technical terrain.

    Is a carbon-plated shoe worth it for trail?

    A carbon plate adds propulsion and stiffness, useful in fast races with little technical climbing. On very technical terrain you notice it less and it can make the shoe less stable. They cost more: check whether your terrain and pace make use of it.

    Do I need a waterproof (Gore-Tex) shoe?

    A Gore-Tex-type membrane shoe protects from water and light snow and adds a bit of warmth, but it breathes less and dries slower if water gets inside. In cold, wet weather it is worth it; in heat or with lots of stream crossings, a non-waterproof shoe that drains is often better.

    How much should a trail running shoe weigh?

    Less weight means less fatigue and a quicker feel; light shoes (under 280 g) prioritise agility. Heavier ones usually offer more protection, cushioning and durability. Choose by distance and terrain, not weight alone.

    Which shoe for an ultra and which for technical mountains?

    For ultras: more cushioning, a comfortable fit and good durability. For technical mountains and mud: more lugs, a sticky outsole and stability. If you run everything, look for a middle ground. Use the multi-compare to put them side by side.