Skip to main content

Asics Trabuco Max 5 vs Brooks Caldera 8

Quick verdict

AsicsAsics Trabuco Max 5302 g5 mm drop3.5 mm lugs

Choose the Asics Trabuco Max 5 if…

  • You want a touch more foam under the heel.
  • You prefer a slightly lower drop (5 mm).
Check price(opens in a new tab)
BrooksBrooks Caldera 8309 g6 mm drop3.6 mm lugs

Choose the Brooks Caldera 8 if…

  • The Brooks fit works for you.
  • You want a stated weight you can rely on (309 g).
Check price(opens in a new tab)

The Asics Trabuco Max 5 is 7 g lighter.

Asics Trabuco Max 5 vs Brooks Caldera 8: weight, drop (5 mm vs 6 mm), cushioning, lugs and which races each one suits best.

Neither convinces you? Compare the 6 trail shoes worth buying

Radar: where each shoe wins

Absolute 0–100 scale, no exaggerated gaps: a tie stays a tie. Asics Trabuco Max 5 leads on 2 of 6 axes.

Radar of Asics Trabuco Max 5 versus Brooks Caldera 8Six axes: lightness, cushioning, grip, stability, technical terrain and ultra distance.LightnessCushioningGripStabilityTechnicalterrainUltradistance
Radar of Asics Trabuco Max 5 versus Brooks Caldera 8
AxisAsics Trabuco Max 5Brooks Caldera 8
Lightness52/10047/100
Cushioning86/10082/100
Grip58/10060/100
Stability25/10025/100
Technical terrain0/1000/100
Ultra distance100/100100/100

Weight: 230 g = 100, 380 g = 0 · Cushioning: 45 mm heel = 100 · Grip: 6 mm lugs = 100 · Technical and ultra: from the stated terrain and use.

Spec-by-spec comparison

SpecAsics Trabuco Max 5Brooks Caldera 8
Weight (per shoe)302 g309 g
Drop5 mm6 mm
Heel stack38.5 mm36.7 mm
Forefoot stack33.5 mm27.9 mm
Lug depth3.5 mm3.6 mm
Fit––
Stable platform––
Waterproof––
Carbon plate––
Terrainsmooth, mixedsmooth, mixed

Brand-stated specs or values measured by independent sources. Green marks the better value when one is clearly better.

AsicsAsics Trabuco Max 5

Trail de máxima amortiguación con FF Blast Plus, 5 mm de drop y tacos de 3,5 mm.

Check price(opens in a new tab)Asics Trabuco Max 5: specs and races
BrooksBrooks Caldera 8

Zapatilla de trail de máxima amortiguación de Brooks para distancias largas.

Check price(opens in a new tab)Brooks Caldera 8: specs and races

Which races does each one suit? Checked against 669 races

For each race we look at the terrain, the distance and the average rainfall around race day in recent years, and see which shoe fits best.

Tied in 669

RaceWhat it needsAsics Trabuco Max 5Brooks Caldera 8
360º The Challenge Gran Canaria260 kmUltra: cushioningBuilt for itBuilt for it
Grand Raid de La Réunion180 kmUltra: cushioningBuilt for itBuilt for it
L'Infernal Trail des Vosges205 kmLikely mudNot its terrainNot its terrain
Topo Athletic Bibracte Ultra-Trail185 kmLikely mudNot its terrainNot its terrain
Tor des Géants330 kmUltra: cushioningBuilt for itBuilt for it
Trail Menorca Camí de Cavalls185 kmLikely mudNot its terrainNot its terrain
UTLAC - Ultra Trail Lago di Como259 kmLikely mudNot its terrainNot its terrain
WOP Challenge Bilbao-Bizkaia224 kmLikely mudNot its terrainNot its terrain

Criteria: mud when it often rains around race day on soft ground; rock for skyrunning and vertical kilometres; ultra from 50 km; mixed otherwise.

Analysis: where they really differ

Two max-cushion shoes for ultras on fire roads and runnable trail, with very similar numbers: 38.5 mm heel stack and 5 mm drop on the Trabuco Max 5, versus 36.7 mm and 6 mm drop on the Caldera 8. Here fit is the deciding factor.

Choose the Asics Trabuco Max 5 if…

  • You want a touch more foam under the heel.
  • You prefer a slightly lower drop (5 mm).
  • The Asics fit works for you.

Choose the Brooks Caldera 8 if…

  • The Brooks fit works for you.
  • You want a stated weight you can rely on (309 g).
  • You want a bit more foam under the forefoot (27.9 mm).
Check price: Asics Trabuco Max 5(opens in a new tab)Check price: Brooks Caldera 8(opens in a new tab)
See all shoe comparisons
Asics Trabuco Max 5(opens in a new tab)Brooks Caldera 8(opens in a new tab)