Skip to main content

Brooks Cascadia 18 vs Merrell Agility Peak 5

Quick verdict

BrooksBrooks Cascadia 18314 g8 mm drop4 mm lugs

Choose the Brooks Cascadia 18 if…

  • Your foot needs a medium-width fit.
  • You want a firm, stable ride on varied terrain.
Check price(opens in a new tab)
MerrellMerrell Agility Peak 5300 g6 mm drop4.5 mm lugs

Choose the Merrell Agility Peak 5 if…

  • You want more cushioning for long runs.
  • You need more grip on loose ground.
Check price(opens in a new tab)

The Merrell Agility Peak 5 is 14 g lighter. The Merrell Agility Peak 5 has more cushioning (39 mm at the heel). The Merrell Agility Peak 5 grips better, with 4.5 mm lugs.

Brooks Cascadia 18 vs Merrell Agility Peak 5: weight, drop (8 mm vs 6 mm), cushioning, lugs and which races each one suits best.

Neither convinces you? Compare the 6 trail shoes worth buying

Radar: where each shoe wins

Absolute 0–100 scale, no exaggerated gaps: a tie stays a tie. Merrell Agility Peak 5 leads on 4 of 6 axes.

Radar of Brooks Cascadia 18 versus Merrell Agility Peak 5Six axes: lightness, cushioning, grip, stability, technical terrain and ultra distance.LightnessCushioningGripStabilityTechnicalterrainUltradistance
Radar of Brooks Cascadia 18 versus Merrell Agility Peak 5
AxisBrooks Cascadia 18Merrell Agility Peak 5
Lightness44/10053/100
Cushioning73/10087/100
Grip67/10075/100
Stability40/10025/100
Technical terrain50/10050/100
Ultra distance50/100100/100

Weight: 230 g = 100, 380 g = 0 · Cushioning: 45 mm heel = 100 · Grip: 6 mm lugs = 100 · Technical and ultra: from the stated terrain and use.

Spec-by-spec comparison

SpecBrooks Cascadia 18Merrell Agility Peak 5
Weight (per shoe)314 g300 g
Drop8 mm6 mm
Heel stack33 mm39 mm
Forefoot stack25 mm33 mm
Lug depth4 mm4.5 mm
FitMediumNarrow
Stable platform––
Waterproof––
Carbon plate––
Terrainmixedmixed

Brand-stated specs or values measured by independent sources. Green marks the better value when one is clearly better.

BrooksBrooks Cascadia 18

An all-terrain trail classic: stable, protective and reliable on any ground thanks to its pivot system that adapts the foot to the terrain. Balanced cushioning for medium and long distances.

Check price(opens in a new tab)Brooks Cascadia 18: specs and races
MerrellMerrell Agility Peak 5

The best value for getting started in trail running. An honest, functional shoe, comfortable from the first kilometre thanks to FloatPro foam, with a Vibram TC5+ outsole offering good all-round grip on mixed terrain. A versatile option without overspending. Weight: 295 g. Drop: 6 mm.

Check price(opens in a new tab)Merrell Agility Peak 5: specs and races

Which races does each one suit? Checked against 669 races

For each race we look at the terrain, the distance and the average rainfall around race day in recent years, and see which shoe fits best.

Merrell Agility Peak 5: better pick in 107 of 669

Tied in 562

RaceWhat it needsBrooks Cascadia 18Merrell Agility Peak 5
360º The Challenge Gran Canaria260 kmUltra: cushioningCopesBuilt for it
Grand Raid de La Réunion180 kmUltra: cushioningCopesBuilt for it
L'Infernal Trail des Vosges205 kmLikely mudCopesCopes
Topo Athletic Bibracte Ultra-Trail185 kmLikely mudCopesCopes
Tor des Géants330 kmUltra: cushioningCopesBuilt for it
Trail Menorca Camí de Cavalls185 kmLikely mudCopesCopes
UTLAC - Ultra Trail Lago di Como259 kmLikely mudCopesCopes
WOP Challenge Bilbao-Bizkaia224 kmLikely mudCopesCopes

Criteria: mud when it often rains around race day on soft ground; rock for skyrunning and vertical kilometres; ultra from 50 km; mixed otherwise.

Analysis: where they really differ

Two all-rounders with almost identical weight (314 g and 300 g). The Agility Peak 5 has more foam (39 mm) and deeper lugs (4.5 mm), but a narrow fit. The Cascadia 18 is firmer, with a medium fit and an 8 mm drop.

Choose the Brooks Cascadia 18 if…

  • Your foot needs a medium-width fit.
  • You want a firm, stable ride on varied terrain.
  • An 8 mm drop suits you.

Choose the Merrell Agility Peak 5 if…

  • You want more cushioning for long runs.
  • You need more grip on loose ground.
  • You have a narrow foot.
Check price: Brooks Cascadia 18(opens in a new tab)Check price: Merrell Agility Peak 5(opens in a new tab)
See all shoe comparisons
Brooks Cascadia 18(opens in a new tab)Merrell Agility Peak 5(opens in a new tab)